Anéantir is the third novel I have read by Michele Houellebecq. The first two I reviewed, Soumission and Serotonin, were memorable expositions of the dark sides of modern life, especially features such as individualism, hedonism, and capitalism. In the present novel, he continues this interpretive scheme and, similar to the texts above, captures some of the deeper currents of modernity that many experience and can relate to but often cannot articulate. These include, but are not limited to, a deep insecurity and a sense of being subject to forces that we cannot control; the individual agency that ostensibly is the supreme value of the modern world provides very few, if any, tools to effectively deal with many challenges, especially related to the end of life.
The title of the book, Anéantir, translates to annihilate, the verb of nihilism, or nothingness, and as reading proceeds, one encounters several different contexts in which this idea is used. By the end of the book, it becomes evident that the major theme is death, and particularly how it occurs and is often experienced in the contemporary Western world: suicide, both “normal” suicide, that is, by one’s own hand, via medical assistance, or cancer. Most contemporary readers, I suspect, have lost either loved ones, close or distant relatives, or acquaintances to one or several of those causes, and therefore have various degrees of familiarity with them. This gives the characters of Anéantir a certain realism which makes it easy to forget one is reading a work of fiction. However, Anéantir also provides glimmers of hope, especially in its portrayal of the main characters, Paul and Prudence, who, in middle age and after a long marriage, rekindle their conjugal love which had, as so often occurs among long-term couples, disappeared.
Assisted suicide, “normal” suicide, and cancer
Many Western countries have in their law books the right to assisted death, although different countries have different regimes. Some, like Switzerland, allow assisted death for almost any reason, while in others, like Belgium, it is permitted for both mental and physical health problems. In Canada, at the time of writing, only those with a life-threatening disease qualify, although there are pressures to expand the options so that more patients, including the mentally unwell and children, have access. When the policy was introduced, defenders stated that only a limited number, those experiencing extreme suffering and near death, would qualify. Eventually, and arguably inevitably, criteria were loosened, and now many who potentially have many years of life ahead of them can obtain it.
In some countries such as Canada or Denmark, it has become a leading cause of death among seniors, and there are serious questions about whether it is being implemented with proper safeguards, especially given the vulnerability of some recipients. I have directly experienced this; when my aged father was in a care home near Toronto, he was deteriorating—he could no longer walk or do anything for himself, could barely speak more than a few words, and had violent twitches, although he did not appear to be in pain. During one of our visits, he was accompanied by a nurse, and during the conversation I said something the nurse did not clearly hear (perhaps because we were wearing masks, as it was during the pandemic), and he replied to me, “you mean euthanasia”? I meant nothing of the sort, and did not have anything even related to this idea in my mind, but the nurse thought I did. This can be interpreted in many ways, but one is that it is a frequent topic of conversation between the staff and visiting family members, and so it was front and centre in his mind; consequently, ambiguity in the communication automatically led to that interpretation.
My dad, in the end, died of natural causes, not euthanasia, one year later, but this experience led me to believe that many families in similar situations are given the option, and many accept it for reasons unrelated to pain, e.g., not wanting to burden others, or from the authority that accrues from medical staff, who present it as a medical option devoid of its moral complexities (there have been many reports of this occurring in Canadian hospitals and care homes, i.e., staff seemingly encouraging the option when the patient and their families are extremely vulnerable).
Houellebecq is a well-known critic of euthanasia, and readers of Anéantir will encounter some of the reasons for his opposition through one of the characters, Édouard, who was a long-time civil servant in the French secret services, a patriot who, his entire life, loved and served his country. In his retirement, he was in relatively good health and in a happy relationship with his second wife, but he suffered a stroke that left him completely paralyzed and unable to communicate vocally. He is otherwise healthy and therefore could potentially live many more years. In the hospital, he is treated well because of the dedicated staff and supportive family, but things take a dark turn when his situation stabilizes and, in accordance with French law, he must leave the hospital and go to the EPHAD (France’s retirement care home system). By now, the regime of medically assisted dying is in full swing and, given Édouard’s condition, he would be unable to oppose it if administered. Moreover, the pitiful state of French finances is creating pressure to reduce public expenditure, and euthanasia clearly helps achieve that objective given how expensive it is to provide 24-hour care to senior citizens.
Édouard’s family, aware that their father will likely meet this fate, decides to take the law into their own hands and hires the services of an anti-euthanasia group, loosely associated with some shady orthodox Catholic organization opposed to euthanasia, and which helps families save their loved ones from such an outcome. The operation goes smoothly, and Édouard is taken to his home where he can be cared for by his family. One reason for the success of the operation was the assistance of Maryse, a nurse at the hospital who helped care for Édouard and who was in a romantic relationship with Aurelian, Édouard’s son. Aurelian was in the process of divorcing Indy, an obnoxious woke Parisian journalist who is perhaps the most unsympathetic character—self-righteous, dogmatic, who politicizes everything, and therefore renders toxic even the most ordinary occurrences, such as family dinner. The relationship had been broken for many years, and Aurelian finally decides to divorce her, and shortly after falls in love with Maryse, a black immigrant to France, who is presented as the exact opposite as Indy: charming, loving, dedicated, honest, and therefore pleasant to be around. When Indy learns about the “kidnapping”, and that Maryse is involved, she publishes a piece about it, and a scandal erupts; one consequence is that Maryse’s visa will be revoked and therefore she and Aurelian cannot continue their life together. In one of the more shocking scenes of the book, Aurelian commits suicide.
Aurelian is, in his own way, a symptom of the modern world. He was the youngest of Édouard’s sons, and was raised in the 90s and early 2000s, when the digital world already played a dominant role in daily life. As is well documented, Aurelian’s generation (“generation X”) is among the most mentally fragile, an outcome not unrelated to some aspects of late liberal modernity. These include online interactions replacing face-to-face ones, political correctness, and identity politics, which includes, inter alia, the idea that words and even jokes can be violent, the medicalization of experiences that in the past would have been understood as normal challenges related to growing up, and the obsession with safety, which has made young people more fragile. Preceding his suicide, Aurelian was experiencing real hardship—going through a divorce, facing the imminent rupture of a relationship with someone he was deeply in love with—but because of his upbringing, he did not have the tools to deal with it. Moreover, like most modern French, he did not believe in the Catholic faith of his ancestors, which would have made him think twice about the moral implications of his decision, given that the Church unambiguously condemns it as one of the gravest of sins.
Cecile, Édouard’s daughter and Aurelian’s older sister, is the only member of the family who has a deep and genuine belief in the Catholic faith, and perhaps not coincidentally, she is one of the more sympathetic characters. She and her husband, Herve, in many ways represent a France that no longer exists. They have been together since youth, and for both, most likely, their union was also their first romantic experience. They have two children and are committed to their families above all else, including personal happiness. They have humble jobs, and their economic situation has become precarious in part because of the changes related to globalization. The simple things in life—a family meal, going to Mass, meeting neighbors—bring them much joy. Despite their commitment to the Church, they are not dogmatic in the least, and especially Cecile displays a kind of innocent and naïve, completely uncynical, love for humanity and for life. In other words, they are the opposite of the stereotypical woke Parisian represented by Indy.
Cécile’s and Hervé’s relation to the theme and title of the book, Anéantir, is perhaps better understood when juxtaposed with Cécile’s older brother and Édouard’s son, Paul, and his wife, Prudence. Paul, in many ways, represents the typical pathway of an upper-class Frenchman—went to top schools, throughout had many sexual experiences before meeting and marrying Prudence (she, too, almost certainly previously had many sexual partners), and has a relatively successful career in the ministry of finance, where he assists and regularly interacts with France’s political elite. They are childless—also a common feature of modern relationships—deciding to focus on careers and other pursuits. As often occurs, after years of marriage, their romance withers away, and they sleep in separate bedrooms, eat separately, and even have separate sections in the fridge for their food. In the meantime, Prudence converts to the Wiccan religion, which more or less is a deification of nature and also very revealing of modern France and, by extension, modern life—the decline of Christianity does not lead to secularism. Rather, new religious tendencies emerge, and Wiccanism fits quite comfortably with contemporary environmentalist sensibilities to revere and worship nature.
Many couples who grow apart this way and who are childless eventually divorce, but the unexpected and extraordinary do sometimes occur, as happens when their love gradually rekindles. As is the case with so much in life, it happens because of almost completely unrelated events. After the kidnapping of Édouard, he goes to live his remaining days in his home with his loving wife Madeleine, which happens to be in the beautiful and luscious French countryside, with vineyards across a hilly plain and forests on the horizon, which, during sunrise or sunset, display a lively interplay of the blue sky, the green vegetation, and the golden sun. Paul and Prudence frequently go to visit Édouard, and while there as guests, it would be awkward for this married couple to sleep in separate bedrooms. The loving environment and example provided by Cecile and Herve, and by Édouard and Madeleine, adds to this mix of natural beauty, an older and purer France, and the circumstances of being guests—that is, away from their Parisian apartment where they had been living separate lives despite residing in the same apartment. When they finally make love—perhaps after more than ten years since the last time—there is a sense of fulfilment, accomplishment, joy, and excitement, in part because Houellebecq has primed the reader to want this outcome, given how sympathetic Paul and Prudence are. I also suspect that many readers who are in long-term relationships that have become somewhat arid will find much hope in these passages.
As is the case in real life, and so in Houellebecq’s novels, these happy occurrences do not translate into happy endings, and here we come to another theme related to the title of the book, and that is cancer. Paul is about 50 years old, generally healthy, without any particularly notable risk factors such as family history or unhealthy habits. And yet an ordinary trip to the dentist for a painful tooth, something almost everyone has to do one time or another, leads to the discovery of a tumor. Treatment options are not good—surgery to remove the tongue, which would permanently disable his ability to speak, or chemotherapy-radiation, which, for this type of cancer, has a very uncertain outcome. Paul wants to avoid losing his ability to speak, and therefore takes a gamble with the alternative, which is not successful. At this stage, his only hope is experimental, potentially promising therapies which, as so often occurs, are not effective.
Here Houellebecq, as with the other themes, captures an important part of the spirit of the times and relates it to the book’s overarching theme. Cancer today is similar to AIDS in the 80s and 90s—terrifying, almost to the point of obsession—in part because it would strike people in their youth or middle age, when one expects to be in their prime. In many ways, however, it is worse; although AIDS was merciless, its victims were mostly people who engaged in risky behaviors (except, of course, those who were victims of medical malpractice, via contaminated blood or medical instruments). Cancer, in contrast, is far more arbitrary, and especially in the contemporary period, many victims are similar to Paul—middle-aged, with no family history, lifestyle habits, or other risk factors. This is something I suspect will resonate with many readers of Anéantir. In my own case, in the past 8 years, three people very close to me, in their 30s or 40s, died from cancer. Because of this experience, I am somewhat familiar with the various phases, including the very end, when traditional interventions like surgery and chemotherapy are not effective, and hope is placed in experimental but untested therapies. This hope derives in part from the modern faith in “science,” which in some cases has an almost religious-like character (this was evident during the pandemic, when disputes over lockdowns and vaccines were framed as “believers” in science and their opponents). The men and women in white coats working in labs have, in some cases, replaced the priests working in parishes as the object of reverence, but, as Paul’s, and many others experience, this is sometimes misplaced.
The modern world does not provide Paul with the tools to deal with his impending and untimely death. Moreover, he must face this just after the resumption and happiness of his conjugal love. What can he do? There are several options available to him in Anéantir. One is the religion of his beloved, Prudence, which adopts the idea of reincarnation; therefore, Paul can expect to return to this world as another human or, in some cases, as an animal. To the question of his impending separation from Prudence, it offers the tantalizing possibility that they may meet again. She too will die and, according to the religion, will be reincarnated, and it is hoped they will somehow be reunited in their future lives (although this depends on the assumption that they will return as the same gender and same species as in previous lives, and during the same time period). Paul finds little solace in this, but neither does he in the possibilities offered by the religion of his ancestors (and his sister), namely, a place in heaven with the creator and/or some future resurrection. He therefore must face the despair of nothingness, or nihilism, which is the logical implication of liberal modernity’s assumptions.
The question posed by this predicament in Anéantir is not whether one religion is true or not, but rather which one helps face the inevitable better. From the characters’ lives, one may conclude that it is the Catholic faith. The most miserable is Indy, the woke Parisian journalist; her obsession with identity politics generates bitterness while young and healthy, and we can deduce that while old and/or sick it will provide little comfort. At the other extreme we see the devout Catholic Cecile, who has a simple, uncynical love for her family and community, which creates a dense network of enriching ties with her neighbours. Rather than prioritizing career, travel, or other individual pleasures, she made the sacrifice and had children with whom she remains very close. Had it been she who was struck by cancer, she would have met the same fate but, unlike in Paul’s case, had the support of children, neighbours, and the church. One therefore gets the sense that pre-secular liberal France represented by Cécile was better at facing the age-old existential questions, and that late-modernity’s cocktail of individualism, identity politics, hedonism, and materialism provides little comfort at the end of life’s journey.